Alright, so I had posted that I had picked a couple of these up at the store. I got the black and nude colors. I got these eyeliners for the main purpose of trying them out in my water line. I have the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Pencil in Zero and I know I’m going to hear gasps but… I’m not a fan, AT ALL. It runs like crazy in my waterline and is gone before I even leave the house. Also, I realize that Perversion is supposed to be more black than Zero but as you will see in the swatch just the Scandaleyes Black is way more pigmented than even then Urban Decay Zero. I wore this yesterday and couldn’t believe how well it stayed on! I had worn it for about 3 hours when I went to do a mirror check to see how it was holding up, I was shocked! It was still on my waterline and hadn’t run into the corners of my eyes nearly as bad as other liners do. There were a few places that it looked like it could be touched up but I’ll admit I was literally two inches from my mirror thoroughly checking it out. I had been out in the wind and cold even so for it to still be in my waterline as much as it was, I was definitely impressed.
They are creamy & smudgeable, if you act quickly but, once dry they aren’t budging! I rubbed my finger over the swatches of all of them and guess what? The Urban Decay smeared and the Rimmel didn’t move. Again… I’m impressed.
Bottom line: Highly recommend.